How do I match that?

This is not a new post, but a repost after a failed WordPress upgrade

One of the projects I am working on is the 3rd edition of Introduction to Bayesian Statistics, a text book predominantly written by my former colleague Bill Bolstad. It will be out later this year if you are interested.

One of the things which will make no difference to the reader but will make a lot of difference to me is the replacement of all the manually numbered references in the book for things like chapters, sections, tables and figures. The problem I am writing about today arose from programmatically trying to label the latter — tables and figures — in LaTeX. LaTeX’s reference system, as best I understand it, requires that you place a \label command after the caption. For example

\begin{figure}
\centering
\includegraphics{myfig}
\caption{Here is a plot of something}
\label{fig:myfig}
\end{figure}

This piece of code will create a label fig:myfig which I can later use in a \ref{fig:myfig} command. This will in turn be replaced at compile time with a number dynamically formatted according to the chapter and the number of figures which precede this plot.
The challenge

The problem I was faced with is easy enough to describe. I needed to open each .tex file, find all of the figure and table environments, check to see if they contained a caption and add a label if they did.
Regular expressions to the rescue

Fortunately I know a bit about regular expressions, or at least enough to know when to ask for help. To make things more complicated for myself, I did this in R. Why? Well basically because a) I did not feel like dusting off my grossly unused Perl — I’ve been clean of Perl for 4 years now and I intend to stay that way — and b) I could not be bothered with Java’s file handling routines – I want to to be able to open files for reading with one command, not 4 or 8 or whatever the hell it is. Looking back I could have used C++, because the new C+11 standard finally has a regex library and the ability to have strings where everything does not have to be double escaped, i.e. I can write R”\label” to look for a line that has a \label on it rather than “\\label” where I have to escape the backslash.

And before anyone feels the urge to suggest a certain language I remind you to “Just say no to Python!”

Finding the figure and table environments is easy enough. I simply look for the \begin{figure} and \begin{table} tags, as well as the environment closing tags \end{figure} and \end{table}. It is possible to do this all in one regular expression, but I wanted to capture the \begin and \end pairs. I also wanted to deal with tables and figures separately. The reason for this is that it was possible to infer the figure labels from Bill’s file naming convention for his figures. The tables on the other hand could just be labelled sequentially, i.e. starting at 1 and counting upwards with a prefix reflecting the chapter number.

Lines = readLines("Chapter.tex")

begin = grep("\\begin\\{figure\\}", Lines)
end = grep("\\end\\{figure\\}", Lines)

n = length(begin)
if(n != length(end))
  stop("The number of begin and end pairs don't match")

## Now we can work on each figure environment in turn
for(k in 1:n){
  b = begin[k]
  e = end[k]
  
  block = paste0(Lines[b:e], collapse = "\n")

  if(!grepl("\\label", block){ ## only add a label if there isn't one already
    ## everything I'm really talking about is going to happen here.
  }
}

So what I needed to be able to do was find the caption inside my block and then insert a label. Easy enough right? I should be able to write a regular expression to do that. How about something like this:

pattern = "\\caption\\{([^}]+)\\}

That will work most of the time, except as you will find out when the caption contains braces itself, and we have some examples that do have just that

\caption{``If \emph{A} is true then \emph{B} is true.''  Deduction is possible.}

My first regular expression would only match up to the end of \emph{A}, which does not help me. I need something that could, in theory match an unlimited number of inner sets of braces.
Matching nested parentheses

Fortunately matching nested parentheses is a well-known problem and Hadley Wickham tweeted me a Stack Overflow link that got me started. There is also a similar solution on page 330 of Jeffrey Friedl’s very useful Mastering Regular Expressions book. The solution relies on a regular expression which employs recursion.
Set perl = TRUE to use PCRE (and recursion) in R

To make this work in R we have to make sure the PCRE library is used, and this is done by setting perl = TRUE in the call to gregexpr

This is my solution:

## insert the label after the caption
pat = “caption(\\{([^{}]+|(?1))*\\})”
m = gregexpr(pat, block, perl = T)
capStart = attr(m[[1]], “capture.start”, TRUE)[1]
capLength = attr(m[[1]], “capture.length”, TRUE)[1]

strLabel = paste0(“\\”,”label{fig:”, figNumber, “}\n”)
newBlock = paste0(substr(block, 1, capStart + capLength),
strLabel,
substr(block, capStart + capLength + 1, nchar(block)))

The regular expression assigned to pat is where the work gets done. Reading the expression from left to right it says:

match caption literally
open the first capture group
match { literally
open the second capture group
match one or more instances of anything that is not an open brace { or a end brace }
or open the third capture group and recursively the first sub-pattern. I will elaborate on this more in a bit
close the second and third capture groups and ask R to match this pattern zero or more times
literally match the end brace }
close the first capture group

I would be the first to admit that I do not quite understand what ?1 does in this regexp. The initial solution used ?R. The effect of this was that I could match all sets of paired braces within block, but I could not specifically match the caption. As much as I understand this, it seems to limit the recursion to the outer (first) capture group. I would be interested to know.

The rest of the code breaks the string apart, inserts the correct label, and creates a new block with the label inserted. I replace the first line of the figure environment block with this new string, and keep a list of the remaining line numbers so that they can be omitted when the file is written back to disk.

Share Button

Leave a Reply